• about me
  • book reviews
    • fiction
    • non-fiction
    • romance
    • fantasy
    • mystery
    • thriller
    • science fiction
  • monthly wrap ups

rainy days and cliches

reading and relaxing in Seattle

what I’m reading: definitely maybe not a detective by sarah fox.

book reviews, books and reading · June 29, 2026

Emersyn Gray is doing her best to raise her young niece, Livy, after life has thrown her more than a few curveballs. She’s lost her job, her ex-boyfriend has stolen all her money, and the only apartment she can afford is in a seniors-only building. When her best friend suggests creating a fake private investigator to scare her ex into returning the money, it seems like a harmless plan. All they need is a business card for “Wyatt Investigations” – no actual detective required! But things get complicated when a handsome stranger named Wyatt appears, the apartment building superintendent turns up dead, and the residents decide to hire the fake detective to solve the murder.

This book was a cute, enjoyable read. I had fun following Emersyn and the residents of the apartment building as they investigated the murder, especially some of the antics they got themselves into along the way. Livy was absolutely adorable and easily one of my favorite characters. Emersyn herself is a bit of a hot mess, which was often funny, although there were a few moments when it became a little repetitive.

One thing I struggled with was the large cast of characters. We seem to meet nearly every resident in the apartment building, and I had a hard time keeping everyone straight. I also didn’t love that there were two love interests. In fact, it felt like every male character under the age of thirty was described as incredibly attractive: Wyatt, Brodie, the detective investigating the case, even Emersyn’s ex-boyfriend. After a while, I started wondering if there were any average-looking people in this city.

I did figure out who the killer was before the reveal, although I completely missed the motive. There are plenty of suspects to keep you guessing, even if I found it a bit of a stretch to believe that some of the senior residents could have been responsible.

Overall, this was an easy, lighthearted read that delivers exactly what I look for in a cozy mystery.

Like this:

Like Loading…

Related Posts

You might also enjoy

what I’m reading: fool me once by harlan coben.
what I’m reading: the ending writes itself by evelyn clarke.
what I’m reading: maybe in another life by taylor jenkins reid.
« 10 things I always say yes to in a bookstore.
what I’m reading: the ending writes itself by evelyn clarke. »

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Hi friends, I’m Shanna, a book lover currently living in the Seattle area! I run on lattes, eat way too many grilled cheeses, and have a never-ending to be read list. Come join me on my reading adventures!

  • book reviews
  • 2025 monthly challenges
  • top ten tuesdays
  • reading lists
  • behind the blog

Goodreads

subscribe via email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Design by SkyandStars.co

Copyright © 2026 · LovePeace Theme by SkyandStars on Genesis Framework · Powered by WordPress.com. · Log in

Loading Comments...
%d