• about me
  • book reviews
    • fiction
    • non-fiction
    • romance
    • fantasy
    • mystery
    • thriller
    • science fiction
  • monthly wrap ups

rainy days and cliches

reading and relaxing in Seattle

what I’m reading: mad about you by mhairi mcfarlane.

book reviews, books and reading · June 9, 2023

Wedding photographer Harriet Hatley doesn’t believe in romance, which is why she has to break up with her boyfriend after he proposes. Suddenly single, Harriet rents a room from Cal Clarke who turns out to be the runaway groom from a wedding Harriet was hired for. As Harriet and Cal slowly become friends, a figure from Harriet’s past reappears who could cause everything in Harriet’s life to tumble down.

I didn’t like this book as much as I’ve enjoyed other books by Mhairi McFarlane. For one, it almost felt like I was reading two different books – the plot seemed very disjointed as the first half of the book was about Harriet breaking up with her boyfriend and then the second half abruptly pivoted to a completely different storyline. I almost felt like I missed something with the second storyline and I went back to the beginning to see if I overlooked some foreshadowing or clues and I felt like there was nothing.

Also, I have some questions about how this book is marketed. From the cover and description, you’d think this is a rom-com but I found it to be actually very serious and deals with some pretty weighty issues that I was not expecting. I’m not even sure I laughed at anything in the book, although this may be because I am not British and there seemed to be a lot of British humor.

Speaking of rom-com, the romance is not the focus of this book and I hesitate to even call this book a romance. It’s more of an adult, women’s fiction book. I did like the focus on Harriet’s growth and development as a character. I loved the scenes with her friend Lorna and the other friendships she forms towards the end of the book.

I was disappointed that there were not more scenes with Harriet and Cal together (another thing I thought I would be getting based on the description). I felt like they spent no time together so although I knew it was coming, I was genuinely confused when they fell for one another. In my opinion, this book suffered from a severe lack of romance.

Not my favorite book by this author, but still a good read and a solid 3 stars from me.


To check out other reviews, find this book on goodreads or amazon. Please note, all links are affiliate which gives a small portion of profit to Rainy Days and Clichés. Thank you so much for your continuous kindness!

Like this:

Like Loading…

Related Posts

You might also enjoy

what I’m reading: dutch girl by robert matzen.
what I’m reading: where am i now?: true stories of girlhood and accidental fame by mara wilson.
what I’m reading: a most agreeable murder by julia seales.
« my auto-buy authors.
10 quotes/for book lovers. »

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Hi friends, I’m Shanna, a book lover currently living in the Seattle area! I run on lattes, eat way too many grilled cheeses, and have a never-ending to be read list. Come join me on my reading adventures!

  • book reviews
  • 2025 monthly challenges
  • top ten tuesdays
  • reading lists
  • behind the blog

Goodreads

subscribe via email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Design by SkyandStars.co

Copyright © 2026 · LovePeace Theme by SkyandStars on Genesis Framework · Powered by WordPress.com. · Log in

Loading Comments...
%d